Falls the Shadow

When you voluntarily help to create or run an educational setting, you do so with an agenda that guides you. You might not be aware that you have an agenda, or you might choose not to examine what it is. But we all have at least one agenda, and probably several, that motivates our behaviour. The role of government, and of regulators such as Ofsted and the Charities Commission, is to ensure that our agenda is an appropriate one. And when it comes to agendas, you get the Good, the Bad, and the potential-to-be Ugly.

I’ve come across various agendas in my time on a preschool committee – most have been completely admirable ones. People have different motivations for doing voluntary work: to help provide a service for their local community; to do good because it makes them feel good; to gain social or professional benefits; to support an admired and respected colleague; to create a great setting for everyone’s children; to create a great setting for their own children; to create a setting that reflects a vision about what is ‘best’ for children; to promote their own interests.

If Tristram Hunt’s parent-led schools are to work, he should consider two key issues around agendas: (1) What happens once my agenda is met? and (2) What happens if my agenda is not appropriate? The answer to (1) is often ‘I move on’: parents typically stay on our committee for the length of time their children are at preschool; parents often move on from a school governing body when their children leave that school. This is completely understandable. Unless there is another pressing agenda in place, why would you continue to give up your free time for other people’s kids? In theory, regulation, good governance and integrity prevent (2) becoming an issue. In theory.

“Between the idea / And the reality / Between the motion / And the act / Falls the Shadow.” T.S. Eliot

This entry was posted in Behaviour, Charities, Early Years, Motivation, Parents, Preschools. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Falls the Shadow

  1. Hi Sue,
    You are right that everyone has an agenda; we all see the world through our own frames of reference. Volunteerism is often a skewed act, driven by personal agendas, which is a problem with the parent-led school approach.

    My bigger concern is the abdication of the SoS role to ensure sufficient school places where they are needed. To agree to continue, albeit in a modified form, the free schools idea as academies suggests to me a continuing adherence to local pressure and market forces, not a firm strategy that can provide sufficient numbers nor quality assurance.

    Platitudes and plasters should not replace coherent policies.


  2. Pingback: Trustee | Freeing the Angel

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.